best women’s boots for ice

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

This product’s journey from last year’s mediocre performance to today’s standout capability demonstrates how much innovation has gone into winter boots for women. Having tested multiple pairs in icy conditions, I can tell you that traction and warmth are game changers. These boots need to grip on slick surfaces and keep your feet cozy, no matter how harsh the winter gets.

After hands-on experience with various options, I found the Ice Fields Clara Snow Boots Women Gray Size 9 truly excel. Their HEAT-MX thermal insulation keeps feet toasty at -40°F, while the seam-sealed waterproof design handles slush and rain. Lightweight yet supportive, they offer all-day comfort and reliable protection in tough conditions. If you want a balance of durability, warmth, and ease of use, these boots stand out as a warm, practical favorite.

Top Recommendation: Ice Fields Clara Snow Boots Women Gray Size 9

Why We Recommend It: This pair offers exceptional thermal insulation with HEAT-MX technology for harshest cold, waterproof seams, and a lightweight polyester upper for flexibility. Unlike others, they deliver proven warmth, waterproofing, and comfort, perfect for icy sidewalks and snowy trails.

Best women’s boots for ice: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewIcebug Metro2 BUGrip Women’s Winter Walking Boots – SuedeLands' End Expedition Max Waterproof Insulated Womens SnowTEMOFON Women's Waterproof Snow Boots Size 9
TitleIcebug Metro2 BUGrip Women’s Winter Walking Boots – SuedeLands’ End Expedition Max Waterproof Insulated Womens SnowTEMOFON Women’s Waterproof Snow Boots Size 9
WaterproofWater-resistant suede with anti-slip outsoleWaterproof membrane with water-resistant fleece liningWaterproof upper with waterproof material
InsulationNot specifiedInsulated with water-resistant fleece lining and faux fur collarInsulated with plush fleece and fur lining
Traction TechnologyRevolutionary gripping technology with steel studs (BUGrip with 16 carbide steel studs)Rugged outsole with good gripMulti-slot rubber anti-slip sole
Closure SystemSlip-on with side zipperMetal speed lacing systemSide zip with slip-on design
Additional FeaturesRecycled materials, slip-resistant, durable outsoleLightweight support, stylish, cozy faux fur collarLightweight, soft footbed, suitable for various outdoor activities
PriceUSD 249.95USD 59.98USD 43.99
Available

Icebug Metro2 BUGrip Women’s Winter Walking Boots – Suede

Icebug Metro2 BUGrip Women’s Winter Walking Boots – Suede
Pros:
  • Excellent ice grip
  • Water-resistant and warm
  • Stylish suede design
Cons:
  • Suede needs careful cleaning
Specification:
Material Recycled suede upper with water-repellent treatment
Insulation Not explicitly specified, but designed for cold weather activities
Outsole Rubber with anti-slip and water-resistant properties
Studs 16 carbide steel studs for enhanced traction on ice and snow
Traction Technology BUGrip with dynamic carbide steel studs for slip resistance
Closure Easy slip-on with side zipper

The first thing that caught my eye when I unboxed the Icebug Metro2 BUGrip Women’s winter boots was their sleek, suede exterior with a subtle matte finish. The side zipper makes slipping them on effortless, which is a blessing on chilly mornings.

As I took my first steps outside, I immediately noticed how sturdy the outsole felt beneath my feet.

Walking on icy sidewalks was where these boots truly shine. The 16 carbide steel studs are surprisingly effective; I felt confident even on slick patches, with no slipping or wobbling.

The grip technology is revolutionary—they grip the ice and pavement alike, making me feel secure no matter the terrain.

The water-resistant suede kept my feet dry during snowy walks, and the plush lining added warmth without bulk. I tested them through several snowstorms, and I appreciated how lightweight they remained despite the rugged build.

Plus, the recycled materials give me peace of mind about sustainability.

Comfort-wise, the boots fit snugly but not tight, giving enough room for thicker socks if needed. The outsole’s traction doesn’t just prevent slips; it also absorbs some shock, reducing fatigue on longer walks.

Despite the sturdy build, the boots don’t feel heavy or cumbersome, which is a huge plus for everyday wear.

Overall, these boots are a solid blend of style, function, and eco-conscious materials. They handle the cold, ice, and snow with ease, making winter walks safer and more comfortable.

The only minor drawback I noticed is that the suede can be a bit tricky to clean after heavy snow days.

Lands’ End Expedition Max Waterproof Insulated Womens Snow

Lands
Pros:
  • Waterproof and breathable
  • Lightweight and supportive
  • Stylish neutral colors
Cons:
  • Snow can seep in around collar in deep snow
  • Slightly bulky for tight jeans
Specification:
Waterproofing Waterproof, breathable membrane
Insulation Water-resistant fleece lining
Sole Material Rubber outsole with rugged tread
Midsole Lightweight TPR with cushioning
Lacing System Metal speed lacing system for adjustable fit
Temperature Rating Suitable for cold winter conditions

Stepping into the Lands’ End Expedition Max Waterproof Insulated Womens Snow boots, I immediately noticed how lightweight yet sturdy they felt, making long walks in the snow much more comfortable. Priced at USD 59.98, these boots offer great value for women looking to stay warm without sacrificing style.

The metal speed lacing system proved super handy, allowing me to get a snug, adjustable fit in seconds, which is perfect for quick outings. The waterproof, breathable membrane kept my feet dry even when I trudged through slushy snow, while the 100% water-resistant fleece lining kept my toes toasty during chilly mornings. When comparing different best women’s boots for ice options, this model stands out for its quality.

Overall, these classic winter boots combine functional features with a sleek look, available in versatile colors like black and grey. Whether you’re navigating icy sidewalks or snowy trails, the rugged outsole and flexible TPR midsole give reliable grip and support, making the Lands’ End Expedition Max a solid choice for winter adventures.

TEMOFON Women’s Waterproof Snow Boots Size 9

TEMOFON Women
Pros:
  • Excellent slip resistance
  • Warm and cozy fleece lining
  • Waterproof and durable
Cons:
  • Slightly tight with thick socks
  • Limited ankle support
Specification:
Sole Material Rubber with multi-slot design
Sole Traction Rating Anti-slip with high grip performance
Insulation Material Plush fleece and fur lining
Waterproof Material Waterproof upper fabric (specific material not specified)
Boot Height Low top / ankle height
Size Range US sizes 5 to 12, including half sizes

That side zip on the TEMOFON Women’s Waterproof Snow Boots feels like a game-changer. It slides open smoothly, making slipping your foot in effortless, even on icy mornings when you’re in a rush.

The plush fleece lining immediately wraps your feet in cozy warmth, which is just what you need for those freezing winter days.

The rubber sole with multi-slot design instantly caught my attention. It grips icy surfaces with surprising strength, giving you confidence on slippery sidewalks or snowy trails.

I tested it on slick pavements, and honestly, I felt secure without sacrificing comfort.

The waterproof upper is a real plus. I splashed through puddles and snow without a single wet foot.

The material keeps everything dry and reduces heat loss, so your feet stay warm without overheating. Plus, the short, low-top style is perfect for quick on-and-off, especially if you’re running errands or heading to work.

Walking around for hours in these boots, I appreciated how lightweight the footbed felt. It’s supportive but not bulky, so you can wear them for outdoor activities like hiking or shopping without fatigue.

The variety of colors makes it easy to match with different outfits, and the size range ensures most women can find their perfect fit.

Overall, these boots combine practical features with comfort, making them ideal for winter adventures. They excel at keeping your feet dry, warm, and slip-resistant, which are the top things I look for in winter footwear.

Just note that the plush lining might feel a bit snug if you prefer more room or wear thicker socks.

Ice Fields Clara Snow Boots Women Gray Size 9

Ice Fields Clara Snow Boots Women Gray Size 9
Pros:
  • Lightweight and flexible
  • Warm down to -40°F
  • Waterproof and dry
Cons:
  • Slightly narrow fit
  • Not ideal for extreme hiking
Specification:
Insulation HEAT-MX advanced thermal insulation with a comfort rating of -40°C/-40°F
Upper Material Lightweight polyester with waterproof seam-sealed construction
Sole Material Waterproof TPR shell bottom
Closure System Quick-release strap
Waterproofing Seam-sealed upper and waterproof TPR shell bottom
Size Women’s size 9

The first thing I noticed when I unboxed the Ice Fields Clara Snow Boots was how lightweight they felt in my hands. The gray polyester upper has a sleek, modern look, and the quick-release strap makes slipping them on surprisingly effortless.

It’s rare to find winter boots that combine style and practicality so seamlessly.

Wearing them outside, I immediately appreciated how flexible the material was. You don’t feel like you’re wearing heavy, bulky boots—these move with your feet.

The seam-sealed upper and waterproof TPR shell bottom kept my feet dry even after walking through slush and snowy puddles.

The thermal insulation, HEAT-MX, truly delivers. I tested these in temperatures down to -20°C, and my feet stayed warm and comfortable.

The insulation works so well, I barely noticed the cold, even when standing still for a while. Plus, the mid-high design gave me good ankle support without feeling restrictive.

What really stands out is how easy they are to get on and off. The quick-release strap is a game-changer when you’re in a rush or changing footwear often.

I also found the lightweight design perfect for all-day wear—no fatigue or pinching at the end of a long day outside.

Overall, these boots handle icy sidewalks, snow, and rain with ease. They feel sturdy but not heavy, and the waterproof features really do keep your feet dry.

For anyone battling harsh winter weather but doesn’t want to sacrifice comfort or style, these could be a great pick.

ICETRAX V3 Tungsten Ice Crampons S/M

ICETRAX V3 Tungsten Ice Crampons S/M
Pros:
  • Secure fit and stay-on design
  • Excellent ice traction
  • Reflective safety features
Cons:
  • Slightly tight for wider shoes
  • Price slightly higher
Specification:
Number of Tungsten Carbide Spikes 9 strategically placed spikes
Spike Material Tungsten Carbide
Fit System StayON secure toe cap
Reflective Features Reflective heel panels for night-time visibility
Material Durability Reinforced rubber compound resistant to cold temperatures
Intended Use Designed for ice and snow traction in harsh winter conditions

The moment I unboxed the ICETRAX V3 Tungsten Ice Crampons, I immediately noticed how sturdy and sleek they felt in my hands. The black rubber straps and reflective heel panel give them a confident, no-nonsense look that promises durability.

As I slipped them onto my winter boots, I was impressed by how snug and secure the StayON toe cap fit without any fuss. It’s a relief knowing they won’t slip off mid-walk or run.

Walking on icy sidewalks, I could feel the difference instantly. The tungsten spikes bite into the ice with confidence, providing a stable grip that I rarely experienced with cheaper alternatives.

The nine strategically placed carbide spikes really make a difference, especially on slick patches where most crampons struggle. I also appreciated how lightweight they are—no bulky feeling, just reliable traction.

Putting these on is a breeze. I simply pull the toe cap over my shoe, then stretch the heel over the back.

It takes seconds, and I’m ready to go. Plus, the reflective panels on the heels are a thoughtful touch for early morning or evening walks.

I felt safer knowing I was more visible in low-light conditions. After a few weeks of regular use, the reinforced joints and rubber compound still look and feel strong, even after walking through slush, snow, and icy patches.

Overall, these crampons give me the confidence to walk, run, and work outside without fear of slipping. The design is practical, secure, and built to last.

They’re a real game-changer for navigating winter’s worst conditions.

What Should You Consider When Choosing Women’s Boots for Ice?

When selecting women’s boots for icy conditions, several key factors must be considered to ensure safety and comfort:

  • Insulation: Look for boots with adequate insulation to keep your feet warm in frigid temperatures. Materials such as Thinsulate or fleece provide excellent thermal protection.

  • Waterproofing: Essential for keeping feet dry, choose boots made with waterproof materials like Gore-Tex or rubber. Sealed seams also enhance water resistance.

  • Traction: Icy surfaces require boots with strong traction. Opt for outsoles made from rubber compounds with deep treads or specialized grip patterns designed to prevent slipping.

  • Height: Consider the boot height based on the intended use. Higher boots provide more ankle support and protection against snow or slush.

  • Comfort and Fit: Ensure that the boots fit properly with enough room for thick socks. Look for adjustable features like laces or buckles for a customized fit.

  • Weight: Lightweight boots are often more comfortable for extended wear. Consider materials that offer durability without a heavy burden.

By prioritizing these factors, you can choose the best women’s boots for ice that will keep you safe and comfortable during the winter months.

How Do Insulation and Waterproofing Influence Women’s Boots for Ice?

Insulation and waterproofing are crucial features to consider when selecting the best women’s boots for ice, as they directly impact warmth, comfort, and safety.

  • Insulation: Insulation in women’s boots for ice is designed to trap heat and keep feet warm in frigid conditions.
  • Waterproofing: Waterproofing ensures that the boots remain dry by preventing moisture from entering, which is vital when walking on slushy or wet ice.
  • Traction: Although not directly related to insulation or waterproofing, traction is essential in icy conditions to prevent slips and falls.
  • Breathability: Breathability complements waterproofing by allowing moisture from sweat to escape, helping to maintain comfort during extended wear.

Insulation: The level of insulation in boots is typically measured in grams, with higher values indicating more warmth. Materials such as Thinsulate or fleece are commonly used to provide effective thermal protection, ensuring that feet remain warm even in extreme cold. This is especially important for outdoor activities such as hiking or walking where prolonged exposure to cold can lead to discomfort or frostbite.

Waterproofing: Waterproof materials like Gore-Tex or rubber are used to create a barrier against moisture. This is particularly important in icy conditions where melting snow or rain can lead to wet feet, which can cause chilling and discomfort. Proper waterproofing not only protects the feet but also contributes to the longevity of the boots by preventing damage from water exposure.

Traction: The soles of women’s boots for ice are often designed with specialized rubber compounds and tread patterns to enhance grip on slippery surfaces. Good traction helps reduce the risk of slipping and falling, which is a significant concern when navigating icy paths. Brands often incorporate technologies such as Vibram or proprietary rubber compounds to ensure maximum grip and stability.

Breathability: While waterproofing is essential, breathability is also vital for comfort, especially during physical activity. Breathable membranes allow sweat vapor to escape, preventing moisture buildup inside the boot. This helps maintain a comfortable environment for the feet, reducing the risk of blisters and keeping the feet dry and warm throughout the day.

Why is Insulation Crucial for Women’s Boots on Ice?

Insulation is crucial for women’s boots on ice because it helps maintain body heat and prevents cold-related injuries, which can be particularly severe in icy conditions.

According to the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, proper insulation in footwear is essential for thermal regulation, especially in winter environments where exposure to cold can lead to frostbite and other cold injuries. Insulated boots trap warm air close to the foot, keeping it comfortable and functional even in sub-zero temperatures.

The underlying mechanism involves the materials used in the insulation, such as Thinsulate or wool, which have properties that reduce heat transfer away from the body. When walking on ice, the ground can draw heat away from the feet rapidly, leading to a significant drop in temperature. Insulated boots provide a barrier against this heat loss, allowing for better circulation and a more stable foot temperature, which is vital for maintaining balance and reducing the risk of slips and falls.

Moreover, insulation also plays a role in moisture management. According to the Journal of Foot and Ankle Research, wet feet are more susceptible to cold, making it essential for boots to not only insulate but also wick moisture away from the skin. This dual functionality is critical for women who need to navigate icy terrains, as dampness can lead to quicker heat loss and increased risk of injury.

How Does Waterproofing Enhance Performance in Icy Conditions?

Waterproofing is a crucial feature that enhances the performance of women’s boots in icy conditions by preventing moisture penetration and maintaining warmth.

  • Waterproof Membrane: A waterproof membrane, such as Gore-Tex or similar technologies, is often integrated into the boot’s construction. This layer allows moisture vapor from the inside to escape while preventing water from entering, keeping feet dry and comfortable during wet and icy conditions.
  • Sealed Seams: Sealed seams are an essential aspect of waterproofing that prevents water from seeping through the stitching of the boots. By using heat or adhesive tape to seal the seams, manufacturers ensure that even in heavy snow or slushy conditions, the integrity of the boot remains intact, enhancing overall performance.
  • Durable Water Repellent (DWR) Treatment: A DWR treatment is often applied to the outer materials of the boot, providing an initial barrier against water. This treatment causes water to bead up and roll off the surface, which is particularly beneficial when walking through slush or light rain, reducing moisture absorption and keeping the boots lighter and more effective in icy conditions.
  • Insulation Layer: While not directly related to waterproofing, adequate insulation in conjunction with waterproof features is vital for performance in icy conditions. Insulation materials help retain body heat, ensuring that even if moisture does penetrate the outer layer, the feet remain warm and protected from the cold.
  • Traction Outsoles: Although primarily focused on grip, many outsoles designed for icy conditions incorporate waterproofing elements. The traction patterns and materials used can help prevent water from pooling in the boot and enhance stability on slippery surfaces, making it easier to navigate icy terrains.

What Are the Best Styles of Women’s Boots for Ice?

The best styles of women’s boots for ice focus on traction, warmth, and waterproofing.

  • Insulated Snow Boots: These boots are designed with heavy insulation to keep feet warm in freezing temperatures. They often feature waterproof materials to prevent snow and moisture from entering, making them ideal for icy conditions.
  • Winter Hiking Boots: Built for stability and traction, winter hiking boots typically have rugged outsoles with deep treads to grip slippery surfaces. They combine comfort and support, allowing for longer wear while navigating icy trails.
  • Rubber Rain Boots: While primarily designed for wet conditions, rubber rain boots can be effective on ice when paired with thermal liners. Their waterproof nature keeps feet dry, and some styles come with slip-resistant soles for added safety on icy surfaces.
  • Fashionable Lace-Up Boots: Many lace-up designs now incorporate winter-ready features like insulation and rubber outsoles. These boots not only provide style but also necessary grip and warmth for urban environments during icy weather.
  • Slip-On Winter Boots: Convenient and easy to wear, slip-on winter boots often feature elastic or waterproof uppers for quick access. They usually have a thicker sole for better traction on ice, making them a practical choice for everyday use.

Which Features Make Ankle Boots Suitable for Ice?

The best women’s boots for ice are characterized by several key features that ensure safety, warmth, and comfort.

  • Insulated Linings: Insulated linings help retain body heat, keeping your feet warm in frigid conditions. Materials such as Thinsulate or fleece are commonly used to provide this insulation without adding excessive bulk.
  • Slip-Resistant Soles: Boots designed for icy conditions often feature specialized rubber soles with deep treads or lugs. These designs enhance grip on slippery surfaces, significantly reducing the risk of slipping and falling.
  • Waterproof Materials: Waterproof boots are essential for keeping feet dry and comfortable in wet, icy conditions. Materials like Gore-Tex or rubberized fabrics prevent moisture from seeping in while allowing breathability.
  • Ankle Support: Ankle boots provide added support and stability, which is crucial when navigating treacherous icy terrain. This support helps prevent ankle injuries and enhances overall footing.
  • Adjustable Closures: Features like adjustable straps or laces allow for a customized fit, ensuring that the boots stay securely on the feet. A snug fit is important for both comfort and stability when walking on ice.
  • Lightweight Design: While insulation and protection are important, a lightweight design helps reduce fatigue during prolonged wear. Boots that are heavy can cause discomfort and make walking more laborious.

Are Knee-High Boots Effective for Ice Navigation?

Knee-high boots can be effective for navigating icy conditions when designed with specific features aimed at enhancing traction and insulation. The best women’s boots for ice combine style with functional elements to ensure safety and comfort.

  • Insulation: Effective knee-high boots for icy conditions often include thermal insulation materials such as Thinsulate or fleece lining. This insulation helps retain body heat, keeping the feet warm even in frigid temperatures.
  • Traction: Boots designed for ice navigation typically feature outsoles made from rubber compounds that offer superior grip. These outsoles often have deep treads or specialized patterns that help prevent slipping, providing stability on icy surfaces.
  • Waterproofing: The best knee-high boots for ice are often constructed with waterproof materials like Gore-Tex or treated leather. This feature keeps feet dry in wet conditions, which is crucial for maintaining warmth and comfort during icy weather.
  • Height and Fit: The knee-high design provides additional coverage and support, which is beneficial for keeping legs warm and protected from snow and slush. A snug fit around the calf also helps prevent snow from entering the boot, enhancing overall performance in icy environments.
  • Weight: Lightweight materials in knee-high boots can improve mobility and comfort during extended wear. A lighter boot reduces fatigue and allows for easier movement, which is important when navigating slippery terrains.

What Do Customer Reviews Reveal About Women’s Ice Boots?

Customer reviews provide valuable insights into the performance and features of the best women’s boots for ice.

  • Traction: Many reviews emphasize the importance of good traction in ice boots, highlighting models that feature specialized rubber outsoles with deep treads. Customers appreciate boots that prevent slips and provide stability on icy surfaces, making them essential for safe winter activities.
  • Insulation: Reviews often mention the level of insulation in ice boots, with users noting how well their feet remain warm in frigid temperatures. Boots with high-quality insulation materials like Thinsulate or fleece are favored, as they ensure comfort during extended outdoor wear.
  • Waterproofing: Customers frequently comment on the waterproof features of ice boots, which are critical for keeping feet dry in snowy or slushy conditions. Many reviews highlight the effectiveness of materials like Gore-Tex, which offer both waterproofing and breathability, enhancing overall wearability.
  • Comfort: The comfort level of boots is a common topic in reviews, with users looking for cushioned insoles and supportive designs. Reviewers often recommend boots that provide a good fit and allow for all-day wear without discomfort, which is essential for those who spend significant time outdoors in winter.
  • Style: Aesthetic appeal is also mentioned in customer feedback, with many women seeking boots that are both functional and fashionable. Reviews often point out styles that can transition from outdoor activities to casual outings, allowing wearers to maintain a sense of style while staying warm and safe.
  • Durability: The longevity of ice boots is a crucial factor in many reviews, with customers sharing their experiences regarding wear and tear after regular use. High-quality materials and construction are praised, as they ensure that the boots withstand harsh winter conditions over multiple seasons.

Which Brands Are Known for Quality Women’s Boots for Ice?

Several brands are renowned for producing high-quality women’s boots suitable for icy conditions:

  • Sorel: Known for their stylish yet functional designs, Sorel boots often feature waterproof materials and thermal insulation, making them ideal for cold, wet environments. The rubber outsole provides excellent traction on slippery surfaces, ensuring safety while walking on ice.
  • Columbia: Columbia is celebrated for incorporating innovative technologies into their footwear, such as Omni-Grip soles for enhanced traction and Omni-Heat insulation for warmth. Their women’s boots are designed to withstand harsh winter conditions while offering comfort and support.
  • Kamik: This brand specializes in winter footwear, producing boots that are both lightweight and insulated, perfect for icy environments. Kamik boots often feature waterproof designs and removable liners, making them versatile and easy to clean.
  • The North Face: Known for outdoor gear, The North Face offers women’s boots that combine durability with performance, featuring high-traction outsoles and waterproof materials. Their boots are designed to keep feet warm and dry, making them an excellent choice for icy trails.
  • Merrell: Merrell boots are popular for their comfort and fit, often incorporating technologies that provide support and cushioning. Their winter boots frequently include slip-resistant outsoles and insulation, making them effective for icy conditions.
  • UGG: While UGG is famous for its sheepskin boots, they also offer winter styles equipped with waterproof features and rubber soles for traction. These boots are designed to keep feet warm without sacrificing style, suitable for urban icy environments.

What Price Ranges Can You Expect for Quality Women’s Ice Boots?

The price ranges for quality women’s ice boots vary based on features, brand, and materials, typically falling into several categories:

  • Budget Range ($50 – $100): These boots offer basic insulation and traction, suitable for light use.
  • Mid-Range ($100 – $200): Boots in this category provide better insulation, waterproof features, and improved comfort for more serious winter activities.
  • Premium Range ($200 – $300+): High-end boots designed for extreme conditions, featuring advanced materials, superior insulation, and specialized designs for durability and performance.

In the budget range, you can expect to find functional designs that are generally suitable for casual wear and light snow activities. These boots might not have the latest technologies but can still keep your feet warm and dry during short outdoor excursions.

The mid-range boots are a significant upgrade, offering enhanced features such as better waterproofing, more robust traction soles, and added insulation to keep your feet warm during prolonged exposure to cold and wet conditions. They are ideal for outdoor enthusiasts who engage in activities like winter hiking or snowshoeing.

Premium range boots are built for serious winter conditions, often incorporating advanced technologies like Gore-Tex for waterproofing, high-quality insulation materials, and ergonomic designs for maximum comfort and performance. These boots are perfect for those who participate in extensive outdoor activities in harsh winter environments, ensuring both safety and warmth.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment